I really liked the boots and wore them during the first NYC blizzard in 2016. BUT got a defective pair bc they leaked! Amazon was amazing and sent me another pair. Haven't worn them yet tho but I'm hoping these don't leak either. I had a another pair of Pajar for four years - so great! They'd still be my go to pair if I hadn't finally accepted that they were too big and had to give them away.I have broken both of my ankles with surgury resulting due to ice. These boots seemed like the perfect solution.. and they are so far! Buuttt... they are waaay too big and sending them back is such a hassle. Instead of ordering a half size up as reccommended, just figure out your EU size.See my review for Pajar Louise; same comments apply. I sent this one back because I could only buy 1 pair so I chose the Louise because the Marcie was very similar style to the one I was retiring so I decided on something a little different this time around.Love my boots. They are light and warm with some traction on ice. Saw them last year and went to buy them and lo-behold there were none to be had. So happy.Warm, fits true to size with room for warm socks, looks good, not too heavy.Love them.Fit as expected and wife loves them as she walks on city sidewalks to work